Skip to main content

Telco CEOs reject satellite MVNOs and keep D2D inside their own lanes

T-Mobile, Verizon and AT&T said satellite does not justify an MVNO deal, while Verizon and AT&T tied D2D to their own wholesale and joint-venture plans.

Telco CEOs reject satellite MVNOs and keep D2D inside their own lanes

Verizon, AT&T and T-Mobile used their second-quarter calls to push back on the idea that satellite needs a mobile virtual network operator deal. Verizon chief executive Dan Schulman said there is “no backdoor to our MVNOs in any structure,” while AT&T and T-Mobile each described satellite as a limited add-on rather than a wholesale substitute.

The clearest fault line is control. Verizon said it wants to work with satellite providers mainly through the joint venture it has with T-Mobile and AT&T, and T-Mobile said it has not seen enough differentiation from satellite to justify a broader partnership model.

Verizon draws a hard line on MVNO access

Schulman said Verizon sees no reason to extend an MVNO agreement to any satellite player. He also said no one can get access to Verizon’s MVNOs in any structure.

That matters because the satellite-MVNO idea had been floated as a way for a space operator to hybridize terrestrial and non-terrestrial coverage. Verizon’s answer was to shut that path and keep satellite relationships inside the framework of the joint venture announced in May.

The May joint venture remains the preferred channel

The joint venture between the three telcos was announced in May to work on direct-to-device and build a wholesale market for satellite D2D around standardized devices and spectrum sharing. Schulman said Verizon wants satellite relationships to run primarily through that structure.

Gopalan said the telcos are progressing rapidly on the joint-venture agreement and that most satellite capacity is expected to be sourced through it. He also said T-Mobile’s exclusivity period with SpaceX’s Starlink for T-Satellite does not end this year.

AT&T treats satellite as reach extension, not a wholesale need

AT&T chief executive John Stankey said satellite helps the carrier reach about 2% of traffic it cannot cover. He said AT&T does not need a wholesale arrangement to address that gap because it can already reach 98% of traffic.

Stankey also said AT&T believes it is building the best converged product in direct-to-device, and said the service with AST SpaceMobile will come to fruition as AT&T moves into next year.

T-Mobile says satellite is backup, not differentiation

T-Mobile chief executive Srinivasan Gopalan said the company offers a significantly better product than fixed wireless access or low-Earth orbit and sees satellite as best used as a backup. He said T-Mobile has worked closely with satellite for four years and has not seen incremental differentiation from it.

Gopalan said direct-to-device remains a complementary service and a small percentage of traffic on the network. He said satellite will stop being a differentiator over time and become table stakes as a complementary service alongside cellular.

What this means for satellite D2D buyers

The message for satellite D2D buyers is that the big U.S. telcos are not advertising an open MVNO door. They are pointing customers and partners toward joint ventures, direct product control and limited coverage-extension use cases instead.

For satellite operators, that leaves the wholesale path dependent on operator-controlled structures rather than a broad resale model.

Verizon sees broadband upside as narrow

Schulman said satellite broadband is unlikely to affect Verizon’s broadband penetration. He estimated the U.S. satellite broadband addressable market at 6 million to 8 million homes, mainly in very rural areas where terrestrial buildout is cost-prohibitive.

That keeps the broadband question separate from the D2D debate. Verizon’s view is that satellite can fill a rural gap, but not move the core broadband business.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Did Verizon rule out a satellite MVNO deal?
Yes. Dan Schulman said there is no backdoor to Verizon's MVNOs in any structure, and that Verizon sees no reason to extend an MVNO agreement to any satellite player.
How does AT&T view satellite in its network strategy?
John Stankey said satellite helps AT&T cover about 2% of traffic it cannot reach. He said AT&T does not need a wholesale arrangement to address that gap.
What did T-Mobile say about satellite direct-to-device?
Srinivasan Gopalan said direct-to-device is a complementary service and a small percentage of traffic on the network. He said satellite is best used as a backup and will become table stakes over time.

DROAM News is published by Droam BV, which sells connectivity services. Droam may be mentioned in or benefit from topics we cover. See our Editorial Policy.